Best Insurance Brokers in Sydney

40 businesses in Sydney, NSW, ordered by the evidence we hold on each one rather than by who paid.

The short answer

The best insurance brokers in Sydney, NSW, ranked on independent evidence rather than paid placement, are General Insurance Brokers of Australia Pty Ltd in Sydney CBD (4.6 stars from 22 reviews, scored 78 out of 100), Mufti Finance in Plumpton (5.0 stars from 186 reviews, scored 81 out of 100), Insurance Union in Sydney CBD (5.0 stars from 38 reviews, scored 77 out of 100), Supreme Strata in Burwood (4.5 stars from 221 reviews, scored 76 out of 100) and City Motor Transport Group in Double Bay (4.6 stars from 121 reviews, scored 77 out of 100). 40 insurance brokers in Sydney, NSW are listed in total. Placement cannot be bought.

Verified 4 October 2026. Every listing is checked the same way, and a check that has not run is shown as a blank, not a pass. How we rank

19 of 40 independently corroborated · 6 with a confirmed phone number · every check ↓

All 40 insurance brokers in Sydney

Ordered by evidence, then by closest match. How this works →

  • General Insurance Brokers of Australia Pty Ltd

    Sydney CBD, NSW

    77.9/100
    4.6from 22 reviews
    • Independently corroborated
    • Website live
    • Phone number matches
    • ABN confirmed
    • Trading since 2010
    (02) 9221 7122Visit website

  • Mufti Finance

    Plumpton, NSW

    80.8/100
    5.0from 186 reviews
      1300 560 297Visit website

    • Insurance Union

      Sydney CBD, NSW

      76.8/100
      5.0from 38 reviews
      • Independently corroborated
      • ABN confirmed
      (02) 7205 6262Visit website

    • Supreme Strata

      Burwood, NSW

      75.8/100
      4.5from 221 reviews
      • ABN confirmed
      (02) 8007 7221Visit website

    • City Motor Transport Group

      Double Bay, NSW

      77.1/100
      4.6from 121 reviews
        (02) 9362 4695Visit website

      • AJB Insurance Solutions Pty Ltd

        Sydney CBD, NSW

        75.0/100
        5.0from 92 reviews
        • Independently corroborated
        • Website live
        • ABN confirmed
        Visit website

      • Omnisure

        Sydney CBD, NSW

        74.2/100
        5.0from 146 reviews
        • Website live
        • Trading since 1982
        • Offers a warranty
        Visit website

      • Everest Risk Group Pty Ltd - Insurance Advisernet

        Sydney CBD, NSW

        74.4/100
        5.0from 5 reviews
        • Independently corroborated
        • Website live
        • Phone number matches
        • Trading since 2003
        (02) 8880 0650Visit website

      • Confio Insurance Services - Insurance Advisernet

        Sydney CBD, NSW

        73.8/100
        5.0from 150 reviews
        • Independently corroborated
        (02) 8918 1888Visit website

      • Eternity Insurance and Financial Services Pty Ltd

        Sydney CBD, NSW

        73.1/100
        4.1from 9 reviews
        • Independently corroborated
        • Website live
        • Phone number matches
        • ABN confirmed
        • Trading since 2012
        (02) 9261 1571Visit website

      • MB Insurance Group

        Sydney CBD, NSW

        72.2/100
        3.9from 8 reviews
        • Independently corroborated
        • Website live
        • Phone number matches
        • ABN confirmed
        • Trading since 1989
        (02) 9966 9777Visit website

      • LA Insurance

        Alexandria, NSW

        72.4/100
        4.9from 30 reviews
        • ABN confirmed
        (02) 9133 9900Visit website

      • Emjay Insurance Brokers

        Sydney CBD, NSW

        71.4/100
        5.0from 2 reviews
        • Independently corroborated
        • Website live
        • Phone number matches
        • ABN confirmed
        (02) 9796 0400Visit website

      • Car Hire Excess

        Sydney CBD, NSW

        70.6/100
        4.6from 87 reviews
        • Independently corroborated
        • Website live
        • ABN confirmed
        Visit website

      • Experien Insurance Services Sydney

        Sydney CBD, NSW

        69.5/100
        4.9from 41 reviews
        • Independently corroborated
        • Website live
        • ABN confirmed
        • Trading since 2011
        Visit website

      • CBHS Health Fund

        Parramatta, NSW

        71.0/100
        4.1from 216 reviews
        • ABN confirmed
        1300 654 123Visit website

      • SHBR Group

        Millers Point, NSW

        69.7/100
        4.5from 16 reviews
          1300 313 509Visit website

        • Bluewell Insurance Brokers

          Sydney CBD, NSW

          69.2/100
          4.8from 69 reviews
          • Website live
          • Trading since 2009
          Visit website

        • Swiss Reinsurance Company Ltd

          Barangaroo, NSW

          68.7/100
          5.0from 11 reviews
          • ABN confirmed
          (02) 8295 9500Visit website

        • Aon Sydney

          Sydney, NSW

          67.5/100
          3.9from 46 reviews
            (02) 9253 7000Visit website

          • Peter Vickers Business Group

            Lindfield, NSW

            68.8/100
            4.6from 10 reviews
              (02) 9496 2300Visit website

            • Nsure Insurance Advisors

              Rosebery, NSW

              66.9/100
              4.4from 16 reviews
                1300 067 873Visit website

              • New Wave Insurance - Boat, Caravan, Trailer & Public Liability Insurance

                Sydney CBD, NSW

                66.0/100
                4.2from 112 reviews
                • Independently corroborated
                • Website live
                • ABN confirmed
                • Free quotes
                • Emergency callouts
                Visit website

              • Coverforce Insurance Brokers (HEAD OFFICE)

                Sydney CBD, NSW

                66.1/100
                4.5from 68 reviews
                • Website live
                • Trading since 1994
                • Offers a warranty
                • Emergency callouts
                Visit website

              • CRM Brokers

                Sydney CBD, NSW

                65.5/100
                4.9from 12 reviews
                • Independently corroborated
                • Website live
                • ABN confirmed
                • Trading since 1999
                Visit website

              • Strata Community Insurance

                North Sydney, NSW

                65.2/100
                3.7from 23 reviews
                • ABN confirmed
                1300 724 678Visit website

              • FreightSafe

                Warriewood, NSW

                66.3/100
                3.9from 85 reviews
                • ABN confirmed
                1300 733 033Visit website

              • Rentsure

                North Sydney, NSW

                64.0/100
                3.5from 13 reviews
                  (02) 9460 2200Visit website

                • Crawford & Company Australia Pty Ltd

                  Sydney, NSW

                  62.8/100
                  2.0from 20 reviews
                    (02) 8202 7400Visit website

                  • Marsh

                    Barangaroo, NSW

                    61.9/100
                    3.1from 30 reviews
                      (02) 8864 8888Visit website

                    • Qudos Bank - Mascot Branch

                      Mascot, NSW

                      62.0/100
                      2.2from 16 reviews
                      • ABN confirmed
                      1300 747 747Visit website

                    • IMAN Australian Health Plans Pty Ltd

                      Sydney, NSW

                      62.7/100
                      1.3from 37 reviews
                      • ABN confirmed
                      1800 221 133Visit website

                    • Need A Broker

                      Sydney CBD, NSW

                      60.1/100
                      1.0from 2 reviews
                      • Independently corroborated
                      • Website live
                      • Phone number matches
                      • ABN confirmed
                      • Trading since 2002
                      (02) 9964 9400Visit website

                    • Howden Insurance Brokers (Australia)

                      Sydney CBD, NSW

                      59.4/100
                      5.0from 2 reviews
                      • Independently corroborated
                      • Website live
                      • ABN confirmed
                      • Trading since 1997
                      Visit website

                    • BAC Insurance Brokers - Sydney

                      Sydney CBD, NSW

                      59.3/100
                      4.8from 22 reviews
                      • Independently corroborated
                      • Website live
                      • ABN confirmed
                      • Trading since 1984
                      (02) 9360 2244Visit website

                    • OnePath

                      Sydney, NSW

                      59.5/100
                      2.2from 15 reviews
                        (02) 9995 1111Visit website

                      • Sydney Insurance Brokers Pty Ltd

                        Sydney CBD, NSW

                        56.5/100
                        4.7from 12 reviews
                        • Independently corroborated
                        • Website live
                        (02) 9211 6111Visit website

                      • EBM Insurance & Risk - Sydney

                        Sydney CBD, NSW

                        56.3/100
                        2.9from 21 reviews
                        • Independently corroborated
                        • ABN confirmed
                        • Trading since 1975
                        (02) 9276 6999Visit website

                      • ii-A Insurance Brokers

                        Sydney CBD, NSW

                        51.9/100
                        5.0from 15 reviews
                        • Independently corroborated
                        Visit website

                      • V-Insurance

                        Sydney CBD, NSW

                        49.3/100
                        3.0from 4 reviews
                        • Independently corroborated
                        • Website live
                        (02) 8599 8660Visit website

                      What we hold on these 40 businesses. Not the site-wide average — the actual list below.

                      corroboration confirmed
                      48%corroboration confirmed19 of 4086% of 22 checked
                      website confirmed reachable
                      45%website confirmed reachable18 of 4082% of 22 fetched
                      phone number confirmed
                      15%phone number confirmed6 of 4032% of 19 compared
                      ABN confirmed
                      55%ABN confirmed22 of 40

                      Other trades in Sydney

                      Looking wider? All insurance brokers in NSW →

                      Insurance Brokers elsewhere

                      Locations with at least 5 insurance brokers.

                      Nobody on this page paid to be here

                      There is no advertising product, no sponsored slot and no way to buy a position. The order comes from the checks described on the method page, applied identically in every category and every location.

                      Read the methodReport a problem