Best Insurance Brokers in New South Wales

211 insurance brokers across New South Wales, ranked on evidence rather than advertising.

The short answer

The best insurance brokers in New South Wales, ranked on independent evidence rather than paid placement, are AVC Migration Blacktown {Australian Visa Centre} in Blacktown (4.9 stars from 246 reviews, scored 89 out of 100), Tank Insurance in Pyrmont (5.0 stars from 102 reviews, scored 87 out of 100), Angelic Insurance in Castle Hill (4.8 stars from 176 reviews, scored 87 out of 100), BRM Insurance in Katoomba (5.0 stars from 77 reviews, scored 86 out of 100) and Ian Hewitt & Associates Insurance Brokers in Penrith (4.9 stars from 90 reviews, scored 86 out of 100). 211 insurance brokers in New South Wales are listed in total. Placement cannot be bought.

Verified 4 October 2026. Every listing is checked the same way, and a check that has not run is shown as a blank, not a pass. How we rank

165 of 211 independently corroborated · 85 with a confirmed phone number · every check ↓

Showing 1–60 of 211 insurance brokers in NSW

Ordered by evidence, then by closest match. How this works →

  • AVC Migration Blacktown {Australian Visa Centre}

    Blacktown, NSW

    88.7/100
    4.9from 246 reviews
    • Independently corroborated
    • Website live
    • Phone number matches
    • Fixed price
    0482 090 086Visit website

  • Tank Insurance

    Pyrmont, NSW

    87.4/100
    5.0from 102 reviews
    • Independently corroborated
    • Website live
    • Phone number matches
    • ABN confirmed
    • Free quotes
    • Emergency callouts
    (02) 9000 1155Visit website

  • Angelic Insurance

    Castle Hill, NSW

    87.3/100
    4.8from 176 reviews
    • Independently corroborated
    • Website live
    • Phone number matches
    (02) 7228 3905Visit website

  • BRM Insurance

    Katoomba, NSW

    86.2/100
    5.0from 77 reviews
    • Independently corroborated
    • Website live
    • Phone number matches
    • Offers a warranty
    • Emergency callouts
    (02) 8076 0988Visit website

  • Ian Hewitt & Associates Insurance Brokers

    Penrith, NSW

    85.8/100
    4.9from 90 reviews
    • Independently corroborated
    • Website live
    • Phone number matches
    • ABN confirmed
    • Trading since 1987
    (02) 4731 5335Visit website

  • Goldstraw Insurance Partners

    Campbelltown, NSW

    85.2/100
    5.0from 60 reviews
    • Independently corroborated
    • Website live
    • Phone number matches
    • ABN confirmed
    0499 506 666Visit website

  • Total Asset Insurance Solutions Pty Ltd

    Bowral, NSW

    84.4/100
    5.0from 51 reviews
    • Independently corroborated
    • Website live
    • Phone number matches
    • ABN confirmed
    0418 256 159Visit website

  • Astute Financial Mosman

    Manly, NSW

    84.7/100
    4.9from 68 reviews
    • Independently corroborated
    • Website live
    • Phone number matches
    • ABN confirmed
    • Trading since 2000
    0434 329 882Visit website

  • AMMF - Australian Motorcycle & Marine Finance

    Bankstown, NSW

    83.2/100
    4.9from 444 reviews
      1300 263 123Visit website

    • Gow-Gates Insurance Brokers

      Maroochydore, NSW

      83.3/100
      4.7from 79 reviews
      • Independently corroborated
      • Website live
      • Phone number matches
      • ABN confirmed
      • Offers a warranty
      (02) 8267 9999Visit website

    • Dudgeon Berry Insurance Group

      Lismore, NSW

      82.3/100
      4.9from 38 reviews
      • Independently corroborated
      • Website live
      • Phone number matches
      • ABN confirmed
      (02) 6621 3000Visit website

    • SEE Business Solutions, Home Warranty Insurance

      Newcastle, NSW

      82.3/100
      5.0from 32 reviews
      • Independently corroborated
      • Website live
      • Phone number matches
      • ABN confirmed
      • Offers a warranty
      (02) 4039 8578Visit website

    • Fisher Insurance Pty Ltd

      Newcastle, NSW

      82.2/100
      5.0from 31 reviews
      • Independently corroborated
      • Website live
      • Phone number matches
      • ABN confirmed
      • Offers a warranty
      (02) 4910 4039Visit website

    • Clearlake Insurance Brokers

      Blacktown, NSW

      81.9/100
      4.7from 111 reviews
      • Website live
      • Phone number matches
      (02) 9037 8970Visit website

    • Rapid Smart Insurance Solutions

      Castle Hill, NSW

      80.6/100
      5.0from 22 reviews
      • Independently corroborated
      • Website live
      • Phone number matches
      • ABN confirmed
      0450 732 962Visit website

    • upcover

      Chatswood, NSW

      80.5/100
      4.9from 829 reviews
      • Independently corroborated
      • Website live
      • ABN confirmed
      Visit website

    • GSA Insurance Brokers

      Blacktown, NSW

      79.7/100
      4.5from 50 reviews
      • Independently corroborated
      • Website live
      • Phone number matches
      • ABN confirmed
      • Offers a warranty
      • Emergency callouts
      (02) 8274 8100Visit website

    • Mufti Finance

      Plumpton, NSW

      80.8/100
      5.0from 186 reviews
        1300 560 297Visit website

      • SPT Insurance

        Katoomba, NSW

        79.5/100
        4.7from 28 reviews
        • Independently corroborated
        • Website live
        • Phone number matches
        • ABN confirmed
        (02) 9525 9311Visit website

      • CPS General Insurance Agencies Pty Ltd

        Chatswood, NSW

        79.2/100
        4.6from 32 reviews
        • Independently corroborated
        • Website live
        • Phone number matches
        • ABN confirmed
        (02) 9493 7999Visit website

      • Dakkan Insurance Brokers

        Bankstown, NSW

        79.2/100
        4.7from 26 reviews
        • Independently corroborated
        • Website live
        • Phone number matches
        • ABN confirmed
        • Trading since 1994
        • Offers a warranty
        • Emergency callouts
        (02) 9707 3077Visit website

      • Unique Insurance Solutions

        Castle Hill, NSW

        79.2/100
        5.0from 16 reviews
        • Independently corroborated
        • Website live
        • Phone number matches
        • ABN confirmed
        0417 270 266Visit website

      • InsuRisk Solutions

        Katoomba, NSW

        79.1/100
        4.9from 18 reviews
        • Independently corroborated
        • Website live
        • Phone number matches
        • ABN confirmed
        • Trading since 2016
        • Offers a warranty
        (02) 7204 0570Visit website

      • Beaches Insurance

        Central Coast, NSW

        78.5/100
        4.8from 18 reviews
        • Independently corroborated
        • Website live
        • Phone number matches
        • ABN confirmed
        0415 510 955Visit website

      • Brookvale Insurance Brokers Pty Ltd.

        Manly, NSW

        78.4/100
        4.5from 32 reviews
        • Independently corroborated
        • Website live
        • Phone number matches
        • Trading since 1983
        • Free quotes
        (02) 9934 9700Visit website

      • General Insurance Brokers of Australia Pty Ltd

        Sydney CBD, NSW

        77.9/100
        4.6from 22 reviews
        • Independently corroborated
        • Website live
        • Phone number matches
        • ABN confirmed
        • Trading since 2010
        (02) 9221 7122Visit website

      • Talk To A Broker - Loans & Insurance For ABN Holders

        Katoomba, NSW

        78.7/100
        5.0from 836 reviews
        • Website live
        • ABN confirmed
        Visit website

      • Elders Insurance Wollongong

        Wollongong, NSW

        77.5/100
        4.9from 12 reviews
        • Independently corroborated
        • Website live
        • Phone number matches
        • ABN confirmed
        (02) 4239 6200Visit website

      • City Motor Transport Group

        Double Bay, NSW

        77.1/100
        4.6from 121 reviews
          (02) 9362 4695Visit website

        • Insurance Union

          Sydney CBD, NSW

          76.8/100
          5.0from 38 reviews
          • Independently corroborated
          • ABN confirmed
          (02) 7205 6262Visit website

        • NewSure Insurance Brokers

          Newcastle, NSW

          76.7/100
          4.9from 10 reviews
          • Independently corroborated
          • Website live
          • Phone number matches
          • ABN confirmed
          (02) 4969 8100Visit website

        • MIH Insurance Brokers

          Dubbo, NSW

          76.7/100
          5.0from 9 reviews
          • Independently corroborated
          • Website live
          • Phone number matches
          • Offers a warranty
          (02) 6882 4007Visit website

        • Momenta Insurance Advisors

          Bowral, NSW

          76.8/100
          4.7from 13 reviews
          • Independently corroborated
          • Website live
          • Phone number matches
          • ABN confirmed
          • Trading since 2002
          (02) 9606 6749Visit website

        • Cover Fast Insurance Brokers

          Castle Hill, NSW

          76.7/100
          5.0from 9 reviews
          • Independently corroborated
          • Website live
          • Phone number matches
          • ABN confirmed
          0430 230 283Visit website

        • SELECTINSURE LIFE- Financial Planner

          Parramatta, NSW

          76.5/100
          5.0from 185 reviews
          • Independently corroborated
          • Website live
          Visit website

        • SELECTINSURE- VIJAYRAJ BIZ INSURE SPL

          Parramatta, NSW

          75.5/100
          4.9from 318 reviews
          • Independently corroborated
          • Website live
          • ABN confirmed
          • Free quotes
          Visit website

        • CIG Insurance

          Hurstville, NSW

          75.7/100
          4.6from 11 reviews
          • Independently corroborated
          • Website live
          • Phone number matches
          • ABN confirmed
          (02) 9915 7000Visit website

        • Le Insurance - Car, Home & Business Insurance Broker

          Bankstown, NSW

          75.7/100
          5.0from 7 reviews
          • Independently corroborated
          • Website live
          • Phone number matches
          • ABN confirmed
          0450 895 589Visit website

        • P.A.S. Insurance Brokers

          Cronulla, NSW

          75.7/100
          5.0from 7 reviews
          • Independently corroborated
          • Website live
          • Phone number matches
          • Trading since 1988
          (02) 9520 0999Visit website

        • Supreme Strata

          Burwood, NSW

          75.8/100
          4.5from 221 reviews
          • ABN confirmed
          (02) 8007 7221Visit website

        • Ideal Insurance Brokers

          Castle Hill, NSW

          75.3/100
          4.9from 79 reviews
          • Independently corroborated
          • Phone number matches
          • ABN confirmed
          • Free quotes
          • Emergency callouts
          (02) 8660 2305Visit website

        • Insurance Brokers of Central Wagga

          Wagga Wagga, NSW

          75.1/100
          5.0from 6 reviews
          • Independently corroborated
          • Website live
          • Phone number matches
          • ABN confirmed
          • Trading since 2004
          (02) 6971 7631Visit website

        • Abico Insurance Brokers - Wollongong

          Wollongong, NSW

          75.3/100
          4.9from 7 reviews
          • Independently corroborated
          • Website live
          • Phone number matches
          • ABN confirmed
          • Trading since 1981
          (02) 4228 1277Visit website

        • AJB Insurance Solutions Pty Ltd

          Sydney CBD, NSW

          75.0/100
          5.0from 92 reviews
          • Independently corroborated
          • Website live
          • ABN confirmed
          Visit website

        • Elders Insurance Batemans Bay

          Batemans Bay, NSW

          75.0/100
          4.5from 10 reviews
          • Independently corroborated
          • Website live
          • Phone number matches
          • ABN confirmed
          (02) 4478 2377Visit website

        • R&M Insurance Brokers

          Newcastle, NSW

          75.1/100
          5.0from 6 reviews
          • Independently corroborated
          • Website live
          • Phone number matches
          • ABN confirmed
          • Trading since 1976
          (02) 4962 4888Visit website

        • Shortland Insurance Brokers

          Central Coast, NSW

          74.4/100
          4.5from 8 reviews
          • Independently corroborated
          • Website live
          • Phone number matches
          (02) 4324 5244Visit website

        • Omnisure

          Sydney CBD, NSW

          74.2/100
          5.0from 146 reviews
          • Website live
          • Trading since 1982
          • Offers a warranty
          Visit website

        • Secure Insure

          Castle Hill, NSW

          74.4/100
          4.5from 8 reviews
          • Independently corroborated
          • Website live
          • Phone number matches
          • ABN confirmed
          0485 585 134Visit website

        • 1st Choice Insurance Services Pty Ltd

          Penrith, NSW

          74.4/100
          5.0from 5 reviews
          • Independently corroborated
          • Website live
          • Phone number matches
          • ABN confirmed
          • Free quotes
          0413 321 926Visit website

        • Everest Risk Group Pty Ltd - Insurance Advisernet

          Sydney CBD, NSW

          74.4/100
          5.0from 5 reviews
          • Independently corroborated
          • Website live
          • Phone number matches
          • Trading since 2003
          (02) 8880 0650Visit website

        • Auto Auto Australia

          Chatswood, NSW

          73.8/100
          4.9from 90 reviews
          • Independently corroborated
          • Website live
          • ABN confirmed
          • Offers a warranty
          Visit website

        • Confio Insurance Services - Insurance Advisernet

          Sydney CBD, NSW

          73.8/100
          5.0from 150 reviews
          • Independently corroborated
          (02) 8918 1888Visit website

        • Driessen Insurance Brokers Pty Ltd.

          Katoomba, NSW

          73.9/100
          4.8from 5 reviews
          • Independently corroborated
          • Website live
          • Phone number matches
          • ABN confirmed
          (02) 9878 7999Visit website

        • Scott & Broad Insurance Broker & Risk Management Solutions

          Katoomba, NSW

          73.9/100
          4.8from 5 reviews
          • Independently corroborated
          • Website live
          • Phone number matches
          (02) 9932 6444Visit website

        • Risk Assist Australia Pty Ltd

          Blacktown, NSW

          73.6/100
          5.0from 4 reviews
          • Independently corroborated
          • Website live
          • Phone number matches
          (02) 9622 0018Visit website

        • Insurance For Living

          Newcastle, NSW

          73.6/100
          5.0from 4 reviews
          • Independently corroborated
          • Website live
          • Phone number matches
          (02) 4925 6125Visit website

        • Elders Insurance Western Plains - Dubbo

          Dubbo, NSW

          73.7/100
          4.4from 7 reviews
          • Independently corroborated
          • Website live
          • Phone number matches
          • ABN confirmed
          (02) 6883 3700Visit website

        • Barrenjoey Insurance Brokers

          Central Coast, NSW

          73.7/100
          4.4from 7 reviews
          • Independently corroborated
          • Website live
          • Phone number matches
          • ABN confirmed
          • Free quotes
          (02) 9918 6744Visit website

        • Dawson Insurance

          Tweed Heads, NSW

          73.3/100
          5.0from 19 reviews
            0418 100 351Visit website

          Insurance Brokers by location in NSW

          A shortlist for your own area beats a state-wide ranking. 2 locations have enough insurance brokers to compare properly.

          What we hold on these 211 businesses. Not the site-wide average — the actual list below.

          corroboration confirmed
          78%corroboration confirmed165 of 21195% of 173 checked
          website confirmed reachable
          67%website confirmed reachable142 of 21185% of 167 fetched
          phone number confirmed
          40%phone number confirmed85 of 21157% of 149 compared
          ABN confirmed
          60%ABN confirmed126 of 211

          Insurance Brokers in other states

          Nobody on this page paid to be here

          There is no advertising product, no sponsored slot and no way to buy a position. The order comes from the checks described on the method page, applied identically in every category and every location.

          Read the methodReport a problem