Best Insurance Brokers in South Australia

53 insurance brokers across South Australia, ranked on evidence rather than advertising.

The short answer

The best insurance brokers in South Australia, ranked on independent evidence rather than paid placement, are Elders Insurance Whyalla in Whyalla (5.0 stars from 36 reviews, scored 83 out of 100), Flinders Insurance Solutions in Salisbury (5.0 stars from 26 reviews, scored 81 out of 100), Webber Insurance Services in Linden Park (4.8 stars from 139 reviews, scored 80 out of 100), Maxton Insurance Brokers in Noarlunga (5.0 stars from 10 reviews, scored 77 out of 100) and KWI in Tanunda (4.9 stars from 10 reviews, scored 77 out of 100). 53 insurance brokers in South Australia are listed in total. Placement cannot be bought.

Verified 4 October 2026. Every listing is checked the same way, and a check that has not run is shown as a blank, not a pass. How we rank

42 of 53 independently corroborated · 20 with a confirmed phone number · every check ↓

All 53 insurance brokers in SA

Ordered by evidence, then by closest match. How this works →

  • Elders Insurance Whyalla

    Whyalla, SA

    82.9/100
    5.0from 36 reviews
    • Independently corroborated
    • Website live
    • Phone number matches
    • ABN confirmed
    (08) 8644 8900Visit website

  • Flinders Insurance Solutions

    Salisbury, SA

    81.4/100
    5.0from 26 reviews
    • Independently corroborated
    • Website live
    • Phone number matches
    (08) 8257 9116Visit website

  • Webber Insurance Services

    Linden Park, SA

    79.8/100
    4.8from 139 reviews
    • ABN confirmed
    1300 932 237Visit website

  • Maxton Insurance Brokers

    Noarlunga, SA

    77.2/100
    5.0from 10 reviews
    • Independently corroborated
    • Website live
    • Phone number matches
    • Offers a warranty
    • Emergency callouts
    (08) 8363 0202Visit website

  • KWI

    Tanunda, SA

    76.7/100
    4.9from 10 reviews
    • Independently corroborated
    • Website live
    • Phone number matches
    • ABN confirmed
    (08) 8562 1956Visit website

  • Be Covered Insurance Brokers Adelaide

    Adelaide, SA

    75.7/100
    5.0from 32 reviews
    • ABN confirmed
    (08) 7092 2242Visit website

  • Australian Pacific Business Insurance (APBI)

    Adelaide CBD, SA

    75.7/100
    5.0from 7 reviews
    • Independently corroborated
    • Website live
    • Phone number matches
    0403 389 579Visit website

  • City Rural Insurance Brokers Pty Ltd.

    Noarlunga, SA

    75.4/100
    4.6from 10 reviews
    • Independently corroborated
    • Website live
    • Phone number matches
    • ABN confirmed
    • Trading since 1995
    (08) 8272 7785Visit website

  • Fundamental Insurance Brokers Adelaide

    Noarlunga, SA

    74.4/100
    5.0from 5 reviews
    • Independently corroborated
    • Website live
    • Phone number matches
    • ABN confirmed
    (08) 7079 5752Visit website

  • Murdoch Insurance Brokers Pty Ltd

    Murray Bridge, SA

    73.6/100
    5.0from 4 reviews
    • Independently corroborated
    • Website live
    • Phone number matches
    • ABN confirmed
    (08) 8532 3200Visit website

  • Elders Insurance Adelaide & Hills

    Adelaide CBD, SA

    73.3/100
    4.3from 7 reviews
    • Independently corroborated
    • Website live
    • Phone number matches
    • ABN confirmed
    (08) 8364 9400Visit website

  • Elders Insurance Southern Vales

    Noarlunga, SA

    73.1/100
    4.8from 4 reviews
    • Independently corroborated
    • Website live
    • Phone number matches
    • ABN confirmed
    (08) 8224 3150Visit website

  • Capstone Insurance Brokers

    Adelaide, SA

    72.5/100
    5.0from 26 reviews
    • ABN confirmed
    (08) 8113 0999Visit website

  • South Coast Insurance Services

    Victor Harbor, SA

    72.3/100
    5.0from 25 reviews
      (08) 7200 5085Visit website

    • Elders Insurance Barossa

      Tanunda, SA

      72.3/100
      4.2from 5 reviews
      • Independently corroborated
      • Website live
      • Phone number matches
      • ABN confirmed
      (08) 8565 8300Visit website

    • Holdfast Insurance Brokers

      Wayville, SA

      72.0/100
      5.0from 14 reviews
      • ABN confirmed
      (08) 8273 0900Visit website

    • Safeguard Insurance Brokers

      Adelaide CBD, SA

      71.4/100
      5.0from 2 reviews
      • Independently corroborated
      • Website live
      • Phone number matches
      • ABN confirmed
      • Trading since 1978
      (08) 8371 0566Visit website

    • Elders Insurance Renmark

      Renmark, SA

      71.1/100
      3.6from 8 reviews
      • Independently corroborated
      • Website live
      • Phone number matches
      • ABN confirmed
      (08) 8580 5999Visit website

    • Westphalian Insurance Brokers

      Adelaide CBD, SA

      71.1/100
      4.2from 5 reviews
      • Independently corroborated
      • Phone number matches
      • ABN confirmed
      (08) 8232 3118Visit website

    • ONE Insurance Group

      Adelaide CBD, SA

      70.7/100
      4.8from 12 reviews
      • Independently corroborated
      (08) 8246 0686Visit website

    • BJS Insurance Brokers Pty Ltd

      Adelaide CBD, SA

      70.3/100
      3.4from 5 reviews
      • Independently corroborated
      • Website live
      • Phone number matches
      • ABN confirmed
      • Offers a warranty
      (08) 8419 4800Visit website

    • Elders Insurance Mawson Lakes

      Noarlunga, SA

      69.7/100
      4.9from 33 reviews
      • Independently corroborated
      • Website live
      • ABN confirmed
      Visit website

    • GIA Insurance Brokers - Adelaide

      Adelaide CBD, SA

      68.6/100
      5.0from 1 review
      • Independently corroborated
      • Website live
      • Phone number matches
      • ABN confirmed
      (08) 8332 4544Visit website

    • Aon Adelaide

      Adelaide CBD, SA

      67.4/100
      2.6from 8 reviews
      • Independently corroborated
      • Website live
      • Phone number matches
      • ABN confirmed
      (08) 8301 1111Visit website

    • Elders Insurance

      Gawler, SA

      67.0/100
      4.4from 17 reviews
      • ABN confirmed
      (08) 8526 9500Visit website

    • Thomas Insurance Brokers

      Noarlunga, SA

      67.2/100
      5.0from 10 reviews
      • Independently corroborated
      • Phone number matches
      • Free quotes
      (08) 8212 7100Visit website

    • Perrymans General Insurance Brokers

      Adelaide CBD, SA

      67.0/100
      • Independently corroborated
      • Website live
      • Phone number matches
      • ABN confirmed
      • Offers a warranty
      (08) 8362 7127Visit website

    • Online Business Insurance Brokers

      Adelaide CBD, SA

      66.3/100
      5.0from 13 reviews
      • Independently corroborated
      • Website live
      • ABN confirmed
      Visit website

    • Elders Rural Services Murray Bridge

      Murray Bridge, SA

      65.3/100
      4.3from 10 reviews
        (08) 8531 9200Visit website

      • Guardian Insurance Brokers

        Mile End, SA

        64.8/100
        4.2from 10 reviews
        • ABN confirmed
        (08) 8238 0100Visit website

      • Island Travel

        Blair Athol, SA

        65.7/100
        4.1from 22 reviews
        • ABN confirmed
        1300 104 070Visit website

      • Elders Insurance Adelaide South

        Noarlunga, SA

        63.7/100
        3.4from 5 reviews
        • Independently corroborated
        • Website live
        • Phone number matches
        • ABN confirmed
        (08) 8187 5300Visit website

      • Ausure City & Rural

        Tanunda, SA

        63.4/100
        5.0from 1 review
        • Independently corroborated
        (08) 8522 3600Visit website

      • MGA Insurance Group

        Dulwich, SA

        62.7/100
        3.2from 11 reviews
          (08) 8291 2300Visit website

        • Austbrokers Terrace

          Adelaide CBD, SA

          61.7/100
          4.2from 10 reviews
          • Independently corroborated
          • Website live
          • ABN confirmed
          • Trading since 2005
          Visit website

        • Bfrank Insurance

          Adelaide CBD, SA

          61.6/100
          5.0from 4 reviews
          • Independently corroborated
          • Website live
          (08) 7078 3566Visit website

        • Hancock Insurance Agencies

          Noarlunga, SA

          61.6/100
          5.0from 4 reviews
          • Independently corroborated
          • Website live
          (08) 8323 8995Visit website

        • iinsure

          Noarlunga, SA

          61.3/100
          4.6from 5 reviews
          • Independently corroborated
          • Website live
          • ABN confirmed
          • Trading since 2010
          Visit website

        • Gallagher Insurance, Risk Management & Consulting

          Adelaide, SA

          59.7/100
          2.6from 16 reviews
            (08) 8172 8000Visit website

          • SSAA Insurance Brokers

            Adelaide CBD, SA

            58.0/100
            4.1from 9 reviews
            • Independently corroborated
            (08) 8332 0281Visit website

          • Insure Today

            Adelaide CBD, SA

            57.7/100
            5.0from 1 review
            • Independently corroborated
            • Website live
            • ABN confirmed
            • Trading since 2012
            • Offers a warranty
            Visit website

          • KE Skilton & Associates PTY LTD

            Noarlunga, SA

            55.3/100
            1.0from 1 review
            • Independently corroborated
            • Website live
            (08) 8337 0006Visit website

          • Assurance Insurance Pty Ltd

            Adelaide CBD, SA

            55.0/100
            • Independently corroborated
            • Website live
            • ABN confirmed
            Visit website

          • GIA Insurance Brokers - Goolwa (formerly The Insurance Office)

            Goolwa, SA

            53.6/100
            4.6from 8 reviews
            • Independently corroborated
            • Website live
            • ABN confirmed
            (08) 8555 3199Visit website

          • GIA Insurance Brokers - Murray Bridge (formerly Managed Insurance Solutions)

            Murray Bridge, SA

            52.5/100
            5.0from 4 reviews
            • Independently corroborated
            • Website live
            • ABN confirmed
            (08) 8532 3093Visit website

          • Elders Insurance Victor Harbor

            Victor Harbor, SA

            51.4/100
            4.3from 3 reviews
            • Independently corroborated
            • Website live
            • ABN confirmed
            (08) 8187 5320Visit website

          • Fully Insured Pty Ltd

            Noarlunga, SA

            48.4/100
            3.7from 3 reviews
            • Independently corroborated
            • ABN confirmed
            Visit website

          • Brian Cotter Insurance Agencies

            Whyalla, SA

            45.1/100
            5.0from 2 reviews
            • Independently corroborated
            (08) 8644 2011

          • M2M Risk & Insurance Pty Ltd

            Noarlunga, SA

            43.4/100
            5.0from 1 review
            • Independently corroborated
            (08) 8410 0154

          • PSB Insurance Brokers Pty Ltd

            Noarlunga, SA

            42.7/100
            3.0from 2 reviews
            • Independently corroborated
            (08) 8361 8872

          • Thompson Insurance Services

            Port Augusta, SA

            42.3/100
            5.0from 1 review
            • Independently corroborated
            0448 657 551

          • Lumley Insurance

            Adelaide CBD, SA

            40.9/100
            1.0from 1 review
            • Independently corroborated
            (08) 8228 1700

          • Oxford Insurance Brokers PTY Ltd.

            Adelaide CBD, SA

            40.4/100
            1.0from 2 reviews
            • Independently corroborated
            (08) 8373 1212

          Insurance Brokers by location in SA

          A shortlist for your own area beats a state-wide ranking. 1 location has enough insurance brokers to compare properly.

          What we hold on these 53 businesses. Not the site-wide average — the actual list below.

          corroboration confirmed
          79%corroboration confirmed42 of 53100% of 42 checked
          website confirmed reachable
          57%website confirmed reachable30 of 5383% of 36 fetched
          phone number confirmed
          38%phone number confirmed20 of 5361% of 33 compared
          ABN confirmed
          62%ABN confirmed33 of 53

          Insurance Brokers in other states

          Nobody on this page paid to be here

          There is no advertising product, no sponsored slot and no way to buy a position. The order comes from the checks described on the method page, applied identically in every category and every location.

          Read the methodReport a problem