Best Insurance Brokers in Newcastle
17 businesses in Newcastle, NSW, ordered by the evidence we hold on each one rather than by who paid.
The short answer
The best insurance brokers in Newcastle, NSW, ranked on independent evidence rather than paid placement, are SEE Business Solutions, Home Warranty Insurance in Newcastle (5.0 stars from 32 reviews, scored 82 out of 100), Fisher Insurance Pty Ltd in Newcastle (5.0 stars from 31 reviews, scored 82 out of 100), NewSure Insurance Brokers in Newcastle (4.9 stars from 10 reviews, scored 77 out of 100), R&M Insurance Brokers in Newcastle (5.0 stars from 6 reviews, scored 75 out of 100) and Insurance For Living in Newcastle (5.0 stars from 4 reviews, scored 74 out of 100). 17 insurance brokers in Newcastle, NSW are listed in total. Placement cannot be bought.
Verified 4 October 2026. Every listing is checked the same way, and a check that has not run is shown as a blank, not a pass. How we rank
15 of 17 independently corroborated · 6 with a confirmed phone number · every check ↓
All 17 insurance brokers in Newcastle
Ordered by evidence, then by closest match. How this works →
Narrow this list
Filters apply to the businesses on this page.
SEE Business Solutions, Home Warranty Insurance
Newcastle, NSW
82.3/1005.0from 32 reviews- Independently corroborated
- Website live
- Phone number matches
- ABN confirmed
- Offers a warranty
Fisher Insurance Pty Ltd
Newcastle, NSW
82.2/1005.0from 31 reviews- Independently corroborated
- Website live
- Phone number matches
- ABN confirmed
- Offers a warranty
NewSure Insurance Brokers
Newcastle, NSW
76.7/1004.9from 10 reviews- Independently corroborated
- Website live
- Phone number matches
- ABN confirmed
R&M Insurance Brokers
Newcastle, NSW
75.1/1005.0from 6 reviews- Independently corroborated
- Website live
- Phone number matches
- ABN confirmed
- Trading since 1976
Insurance For Living
Newcastle, NSW
73.6/1005.0from 4 reviews- Independently corroborated
- Website live
- Phone number matches
Aon Newcastle
Newcastle, NSW
71.0/1003.8from 4 reviews- Independently corroborated
- Website live
- Phone number matches
- ABN confirmed
Newcastle Insurance Group
Newcastle, NSW
69.9/1004.7from 54 reviews- Independently corroborated
- Website live
- ABN confirmed
Vital Financial Group
Newcastle, NSW
67.7/1004.9from 91 reviews- Independently corroborated
Elders Insurance Newcastle
Wallsend, NSW
66.3/1004.1from 31 reviews- ABN confirmed
Markey Insurance & Risk
Newcastle, NSW
63.0/1004.4from 12 reviews- Independently corroborated
- Website live
FloorInsure
Newcastle, NSW
63.1/1005.0from 6 reviews- Independently corroborated
- Website live
- ABN confirmed
- Trading since 1987
- Free quotes
Ausure Insurance Newcastle
Newcastle, NSW
62.5/1005.0from 11 reviews- Independently corroborated
Phoenix Risk Services
Newcastle, NSW
58.2/1005.0from 2 reviews- Independently corroborated
- ABN confirmed
- Trading since 2000
ACSIS LTD
Newcastle, NSW
57.7/1005.0from 1 review- Independently corroborated
- Website live
- ABN confirmed
Insurance House 360 - Newcastle
Newcastle, NSW
53.6/1005.0from 4 reviews- Independently corroborated
- Website live
Austbrokers Holdings Ltd.
Charlestown, NSW
43.4/1005.0from 1 review- Independently corroborated
What we hold on these 17 businesses. Not the site-wide average — the actual list below.
- corroboration confirmed
- 88%corroboration confirmed15 of 1794% of 16 checked
- website confirmed reachable
- 65%website confirmed reachable11 of 1773% of 15 fetched
- phone number confirmed
- 35%phone number confirmed6 of 1750% of 12 compared
- ABN confirmed
- 59%ABN confirmed10 of 17
Other trades in Newcastle
Looking wider? All insurance brokers in NSW →
Insurance Brokers elsewhere
Locations with at least 5 insurance brokers.
Nobody on this page paid to be here
There is no advertising product, no sponsored slot and no way to buy a position. The order comes from the checks described on the method page, applied identically in every category and every location.