Best Insurance Brokers in Melbourne

60 businesses in Melbourne, VIC, ordered by the evidence we hold on each one rather than by who paid.

The short answer

The best insurance brokers in Melbourne, VIC, ranked on independent evidence rather than paid placement, are McKenzie Ross Business Insurance Brokers in Melbourne CBD (4.9 stars from 109 reviews, scored 87 out of 100), Astute Financial Melbourne City South in Melbourne CBD (4.9 stars from 91 reviews, scored 86 out of 100), Fundamental Insurance Brokers Melbourne in Melbourne CBD (4.9 stars from 58 reviews, scored 84 out of 100), Tony Insurance in Melbourne CBD (5.0 stars from 49 reviews, scored 83 out of 100) and Midland Insurance Brokers in Melbourne CBD (4.7 stars from 69 reviews, scored 83 out of 100). 60 insurance brokers in Melbourne, VIC are listed in total. Placement cannot be bought.

Verified 4 October 2026. Every listing is checked the same way, and a check that has not run is shown as a blank, not a pass. How we rank

30 of 60 independently corroborated · 15 with a confirmed phone number · every check ↓

All 60 insurance brokers in Melbourne

Ordered by evidence, then by closest match. How this works →

  • McKenzie Ross Business Insurance Brokers

    Melbourne CBD, VIC

    86.6/100
    4.9from 109 reviews
    • Independently corroborated
    • Website live
    • Phone number matches
    • ABN confirmed
    • Offers a warranty
    (03) 9691 2222Visit website

  • Astute Financial Melbourne City South

    Melbourne CBD, VIC

    85.9/100
    4.9from 91 reviews
    • Independently corroborated
    • Website live
    • Phone number matches
    • ABN confirmed
    • Trading since 2001
    (03) 9820 0451Visit website

  • Fundamental Insurance Brokers Melbourne

    Melbourne CBD, VIC

    84.0/100
    4.9from 58 reviews
    • Independently corroborated
    • Website live
    • Phone number matches
    • ABN confirmed
    (03) 8595 5435Visit website

  • Tony Insurance

    Melbourne CBD, VIC

    83.0/100
    5.0from 49 reviews
    • Independently corroborated
    • Phone number matches
    • ABN confirmed
    0433 227 711Visit website

  • Midland Insurance Brokers

    Melbourne CBD, VIC

    82.8/100
    4.7from 69 reviews
    • Independently corroborated
    • Website live
    • Phone number matches
    • ABN confirmed
    • Trading since 1986
    • Free quotes
    (03) 9349 2733Visit website

  • Comparify Health Insurance

    South Yarra, VIC

    81.2/100
    4.9from 266 reviews
    • ABN confirmed
    1300 672 067Visit website

  • Hewison Private Wealth

    Melbourne, VIC

    81.6/100
    5.0from 128 reviews
    • ABN confirmed
    (03) 8548 4800Visit website

  • KT Insurance

    Melbourne, VIC

    81.4/100
    4.6from 402 reviews
      1300 261 261Visit website

    • EBM Insurance & Risk - Melbourne

      Melbourne CBD, VIC

      79.5/100
      4.7from 28 reviews
      • Independently corroborated
      • Website live
      • Phone number matches
      • ABN confirmed
      • Trading since 1975
      (03) 9425 1890Visit website

    • GCIS Insurance

      Camberwell, VIC

      78.1/100
      5.0from 54 reviews
        0431 131 961Visit website

      • Moran Insurance Brokers

        Melbourne CBD, VIC

        76.2/100
        5.0from 8 reviews
        • Independently corroborated
        • Website live
        • Phone number matches
        • Trading since 1979
        (03) 9427 0288Visit website

      • DGA Insurance Brokers

        Melbourne CBD, VIC

        75.6/100
        4.4from 15 reviews
        • Independently corroborated
        • Website live
        • Phone number matches
        • ABN confirmed
        • Free quotes
        (03) 8636 9000Visit website

      • onefocus

        Melbourne CBD, VIC

        75.3/100
        4.9from 7 reviews
        • Independently corroborated
        • Website live
        • Phone number matches
        • Trading since 1967
        (03) 9861 6100Visit website

      • iLink Insurance Brokers

        Mount Waverley, VIC

        76.7/100
        5.0from 67 reviews
        • ABN confirmed
        1300 170 328Visit website

      • Recoveries Corporation Pty Ltd

        Melbourne, VIC

        72.0/100
        1.2from 483 reviews
          1300 663 060Visit website

        • Synergy Insurance Brokers

          Kew East, VIC

          72.8/100
          4.8from 23 reviews
          • ABN confirmed
          (03) 9859 7089Visit website

        • Modulus Insurance

          Port Melbourne, VIC

          72.7/100
          5.0from 27 reviews
          • ABN confirmed
          (03) 9100 7999Visit website

        • Yes Insurance Group

          Melbourne CBD, VIC

          71.6/100
          4.5from 162 reviews
          • Independently corroborated
          • Website live
          • ABN confirmed
          • Free quotes
          Visit website

        • ADK Insurance Brokers

          Melbourne CBD, VIC

          71.4/100
          5.0from 2 reviews
          • Independently corroborated
          • Website live
          • Phone number matches
          • ABN confirmed
          • Trading since 2008
          (03) 9340 1800Visit website

        • Safety Nest Pty Ltd

          Balaclava, VIC

          72.0/100
          5.0from 23 reviews
          • ABN confirmed
          1300 055 922Visit website

        • Unique Insurance Group

          Williamstown North, VIC

          73.1/100
          4.7from 56 reviews
          • ABN confirmed
          1300 275 844Visit website

        • ATIA Insurance Services

          Melbourne CBD, VIC

          70.3/100
          3.4from 5 reviews
          • Independently corroborated
          • Website live
          • Phone number matches
          • ABN confirmed
          (03) 9642 4622Visit website

        • Maynard & Barrett Insurance Services

          Elsternwick, VIC

          71.5/100
          5.0from 21 reviews
          • ABN confirmed
          (03) 9103 1392Visit website

        • ProTrades Insurance

          Melbourne CBD, VIC

          69.9/100
          5.0from 51 reviews
          • Website live
          • ABN confirmed
          • Free quotes
          Visit website

        • Assured Insurance Brokers

          Melbourne CBD, VIC

          69.7/100
          5.0from 1 review
          • Independently corroborated
          • Website live
          • Phone number matches
          (03) 9665 2750Visit website

        • Interpacific Insurance Brokers

          Melbourne CBD, VIC

          69.7/100
          5.0from 1 review
          • Independently corroborated
          • Website live
          • Phone number matches
          • ABN confirmed
          (03) 9696 6099Visit website

        • Lifebroker

          Melbourne CBD, VIC

          69.6/100
          4.6from 66 reviews
          • Independently corroborated
          • Website live
          • ABN confirmed
          Visit website

        • United Insurance Group

          Melbourne CBD, VIC

          69.3/100
          3.0from 4 reviews
          • Independently corroborated
          • Website live
          • Phone number matches
          (03) 8676 0344Visit website

        • Fenton Green & Co

          Cremorne, VIC

          68.2/100
          4.6from 17 reviews
          • ABN confirmed
          1800 642 747Visit website

        • Consolidated Insurance Agencies

          Clayton, VIC

          71.6/100
          4.7from 37 reviews
          • ABN confirmed
          1300 446 787Visit website

        • AB Phillips

          Moorabbin, VIC

          70.7/100
          4.5from 47 reviews
          • ABN confirmed
          1300 242 136Visit website

        • Easy Refunds

          Docklands, VIC

          68.7/100
          5.0from 11 reviews
            (03) 9913 6896Visit website

          • BJS Insurance Brokers

            Melbourne, VIC

            67.4/100
            4.8from 10 reviews
              (03) 9860 4200Visit website

            • DanceSurance

              Wantirna South, VIC

              70.5/100
              4.9from 11 reviews
                1300 552 205Visit website

              • LAI Insurance Brokers Lt Collins St

                Melbourne CBD, VIC

                67.0/100
                • Independently corroborated
                • Website live
                • Phone number matches
                • ABN confirmed
                • Free quotes
                0421 783 011Visit website

              • Fortitude Insurance Group

                Airport West, VIC

                69.1/100
                4.6from 11 reviews
                  (03) 8001 8600Visit website

                • Life Insurance 4 U

                  Clarinda, VIC

                  69.1/100
                  5.0from 12 reviews
                    0449 903 033Visit website

                  • City Taxi Club Inc

                    Tullamarine, VIC

                    68.9/100
                    4.3from 48 reviews
                      (03) 8597 0739Visit website

                    • EBM RentCover

                      Burnley, VIC

                      63.3/100
                      3.7from 40 reviews
                      • ABN confirmed
                      1800 661 662Visit website

                    • PNOinsurance

                      Malvern East, VIC

                      65.1/100
                      3.7from 16 reviews
                      • ABN confirmed
                      (03) 9536 7333Visit website

                    • Marsh

                      Melbourne, VIC

                      62.8/100
                      2.4from 38 reviews
                        (03) 9603 2222Visit website

                      • Australian Insurance Services Alliance (AISA)

                        Melbourne CBD, VIC

                        62.4/100
                        5.0from 5 reviews
                        • Independently corroborated
                        • Website live
                        (03) 9621 2422Visit website

                      • Benjamin & Benjamin Insurance Group

                        Melbourne CBD, VIC

                        62.4/100
                        5.0from 5 reviews
                        • Independently corroborated
                        • Website live
                        Visit website

                      • Express Insurance

                        Cremorne, VIC

                        60.1/100
                        3.2from 15 reviews
                          1300 464 989Visit website

                        • Victoria Rideshare Cover

                          Derrimut, VIC

                          63.8/100
                          3.4from 27 reviews
                            (03) 9069 7861Visit website

                          • State Claims

                            Craigieburn, VIC

                            63.4/100
                            4.9from 61 reviews
                              Visit website

                            • Whitbread Insurance Brokers

                              Melbourne, VIC

                              59.5/100
                              2.6from 15 reviews
                              • ABN confirmed
                              1300 424 627Visit website

                            • Famous Insurance

                              Melbourne CBD, VIC

                              59.8/100
                              3.5from 40 reviews
                              • Independently corroborated
                              • Website live
                              Visit website

                            • Australia Underwriting

                              Melbourne CBD, VIC

                              59.4/100
                              5.0from 2 reviews
                              • Independently corroborated
                              • Website live
                              • ABN confirmed
                              Visit website

                            • Victorian Managed Insurance Authority

                              Melbourne CBD, VIC

                              58.7/100
                              2.1from 83 reviews
                                Visit website

                              • Jim’s Insurance

                                Mooroolbark, VIC

                                60.7/100
                                3.3from 14 reviews
                                • ABN confirmed
                                1300 546 000Visit website

                              • Landlords Insurance

                                Melbourne CBD, VIC

                                55.0/100
                                • Independently corroborated
                                • Website live
                                • ABN confirmed
                                Visit website

                              • Agripro Insurance Brokers

                                Melbourne CBD, VIC

                                55.0/100
                                • Independently corroborated
                                • Website live
                                • ABN confirmed
                                Visit website

                              • Strata Insurance

                                Melbourne CBD, VIC

                                55.0/100
                                • Independently corroborated
                                • Website live
                                • ABN confirmed
                                • Trading since 2015
                                Visit website

                              • CTRS TAXI AND RIDESHARE CLUB REPAIRS

                                Glen Waverley, VIC

                                56.8/100
                                4.6from 139 reviews
                                • Independently corroborated
                                (03) 9112 5585

                              • Capital Means

                                Melbourne CBD, VIC

                                53.0/100
                                5.0from 19 reviews
                                • Independently corroborated
                                Visit website

                              • AIC Insurance Brokers

                                Melbourne CBD, VIC

                                49.7/100
                                5.0from 1 review
                                • Independently corroborated
                                • Website live
                                • ABN confirmed
                                • Trading since 1982
                                (03) 9857 6987Visit website

                              • Heron Insurance Group

                                Melbourne CBD, VIC

                                46.3/100
                                5.0from 3 reviews
                                • Independently corroborated
                                0439 503 015

                              • 1300 Insurance

                                Melbourne CBD, VIC

                                44.3/100
                                3.7from 7 reviews
                                • Independently corroborated
                                Visit website

                              • Solution Underwriting Agency

                                Melbourne CBD, VIC

                                24.9/100
                                5.0from 1 review
                                • Independently corroborated

                              What we hold on these 60 businesses. Not the site-wide average — the actual list below.

                              corroboration confirmed
                              50%corroboration confirmed30 of 6094% of 32 checked
                              website confirmed reachable
                              42%website confirmed reachable25 of 6089% of 28 fetched
                              phone number confirmed
                              25%phone number confirmed15 of 6056% of 27 compared
                              ABN confirmed
                              57%ABN confirmed34 of 60

                              Other trades in Melbourne

                              Looking wider? All insurance brokers in VIC →

                              Insurance Brokers elsewhere

                              Locations with at least 5 insurance brokers.

                              Nobody on this page paid to be here

                              There is no advertising product, no sponsored slot and no way to buy a position. The order comes from the checks described on the method page, applied identically in every category and every location.

                              Read the methodReport a problem